Our legal and psychological Expertise

From 2019 to 2021, Dr. Chu served as a clinical psychologist at the Los Angeles County Department of Mental Health (Juvenile Justice Mental Health Program, Dorothy Kirby Center). Throughout her tenure, Dr. Chu completed a wide array of training courses through the National Institute of Corrections (NIC), U.S. Department of Justice. While working within the criminal justice system, she reviewed a diverse range of expert evaluations and provided effective treatment to underrepresented juvenile adolescents who faced felony and misdemeanor charges, including first-degree murder, manslaughter, terrorism, assault, rape, possession of controlled substances, and armed burglary.
Criminal Forensic Evaluations
Criminal forensic evaluations are conducted in criminal cases to determine the defendant’s mental state and behavior. Such evaluations determine whether the defendant is competent to stand trial, had the mental capacity to understand the nature and consequences of their actions at the time of the crime, or was under the influence of drugs or alcohol at the time of the offense. These evaluations are also used to determine the defendant’s reoffending risk and to provide treatment or intervention recommendations.
What types of cases require a forensic psychological evaluation?
The most common types of cases that require forensic psychological evaluations include Competency to Stand Trial, Criminal Responsibility (Insanity Defense), Risk Assessment, Mental Health Diversion, Child Custody and Parental Fitness, Juvenile Delinquency, Personal Injury Claims, Disability Claims, Sex Offender Evaluations, Fitness for Duty Evaluations, and Immigration Cases, etc.
What is the process of conducting a forensic psychological evaluation?
The process of conducting a forensic psychological evaluation involves the following:
What is the difference between criminal and civil forensic evaluation?
Forensic psychological evaluations can be broadly categorized into criminal and civil evaluations, each serving different purposes and addressing distinct legal questions, while civil forensic evaluations are conducted to address psychological issues that arise in the context of civil legal matters.
Key Takeaways:
Forensic psychological evaluations are crucial tools for the legal system to gain insights into an individual’s mental state and behavior. These assessments serve to aid the court in making informed decisions regarding mental health-related matters. Whether it is a criminal or civil case, forensic evaluations play a significant role in providing valuable information that can shape the outcome of legal proceedings. Understanding the importance and process of forensic evaluations helps us appreciate the significant impact they have on the justice system.

CALIFORNIA NOT GUILTY BY REASON OF INSANITY (NGRI) EVALUATIONS
Penal Code §§ 25, 1026, and 1027
FORENSIC EVALUATION OF LEGAL SANITY
A Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity (NGRI) evaluation is a specialized forensic psychological assessment that addresses the defendant's mental condition at the time of the alleged offense. Unlike competency evaluations, which examine a defendant's present ability to participate in legal proceedings, an NGRI evaluation requires a careful, retrospective reconstruction of the defendant's psychological functioning at the relevant time.
The evaluation is conducted independently and objectively, with opinions based on the integration of clinical findings, psychological assessment data, contemporaneous records, collateral information, and other relevant evidence.
Legal Question: Under California law, the evaluation examines whether, due to a mental disease or defect, the defendant was incapable at the time of the offense of:
-
Knowing and understanding the nature and quality of the act.
-
Knowing or understanding that the act was morally or legally wrong.
The presence of a psychiatric diagnosis alone does not establish legal insanity. The forensic analysis focuses on the relationship between the defendant's mental condition and the specific legal criteria applicable at the time of the alleged offense.
RETROSPECTIVE FORENSIC ANALYSIS
Reconstructing a defendant's past mental state requires a careful examination of the evidence surrounding the alleged offense. Particular attention is given to the defendant's reported symptoms and behavior before, during, and after the event; statements attributed to the defendant; psychiatric and treatment history; contemporaneous documentation; collateral accounts; and behavioral evidence relevant to the defendant's understanding and functioning.
The examiner examines consistency and discrepancies across information sources and considers reasonable alternative explanations for the defendant's presentation before formulating a forensic opinion.
EVALUATION PROCESS
Depending on the referral question and circumstances of the case, the evaluation may include:
-
Comprehensive forensic psychological interview
-
Review of police and investigative reports.
-
Review of psychiatric, psychological, medical, and treatment records.
-
Review of prior forensic or psychological evaluations.
-
Psychological and diagnostic testing, when indicated, can help evaluate cognitive function, personality traits, and mental health conditions. These tests are administered by trained professionals and provide valuable insights for diagnosis, treatment planning, and research purposes.
-
Assessment of response validity, symptom exaggeration, and possible feigning.
-
Collateral interviews, when relevant, are conducted.
-
Analysis of behavioral evidence surrounding the alleged offense.
-
Integration of findings with the applicable California legal standards.
No single diagnosis, test result, statement, or piece of evidence is considered determinative. Forensic opinions are developed through the systematic integration of multiple data sources and the consideration of alternative explanations and limitations.
Independent & Objective Forensic Opinions
The evaluator's role is not to advocate for either party. The purpose of the evaluation is to provide an independent, evidence-based psychological opinion that assists the retaining counsel and, when applicable, the court in understanding the psychological evidence relevant to legal sanity.
The ultimate determination of legal insanity remains with the trier of fact.
SERVICES AVAILABLE
NGRI/Legal Sanity Evaluations
A comprehensive retrospective evaluation of the defendant's mental condition at the time of the alleged offense.
Independent and Rebuttal Evaluations
Review and analysis of another expert's methodology, assessment data, reasoning, and forensic conclusions, when appropriate.
Attorney Consultation
Pre- and post-evaluation consultations are conducted regarding referral questions, psychological evidence, assessment findings, and relevant forensic issues.
Written Forensic Reports
Clearly organized reports integrate records, assessment data, clinical findings, forensic reasoning, limitations, and opinions in response to the legal question presented.
Depositions and Expert Testimony
Available when testimony is required regarding the evaluation, methodology, findings, or forensic opinions.
REFERRALS
Referrals are accepted from defense counsel, prosecuting agencies, and courts throughout California, subject to case-specific requirements and availability.
FORENSIC APPROACH
NGRI evaluations require more than determining whether a defendant has a mental disorder; they require careful reconstruction of psychological functioning at a specific point in time and analysis of whether the available evidence supports the applicable legal criteria.
Each evaluation is approached with independence, objectivity, attention to evidentiary detail, assessment of response validity, consideration of alternative explanations, and a clear separation of clinical diagnosis from the legal determination of insanity.


